Album Review: Wayfarer - Riders of the Setting Sun (Vesperian, 2026)
7 minutes ago
8 min read

Written: 15th November 2026
Colorado’s Wayfarer have spent more than a decade developing their unique blend of atmospheric black / folk metal and gothic country music. Add in their love of mythology, history and the American West and you might be close to understanding what Wayfarer have offered in the past. This amalgamation of ideas reached its peak with their excellent 2023 release, which they simply named American Gothic. With that album being so well received, it must have been tempting for Wayfarer to try to repeat the formula. However, they have never been a band to simply rehash ideas and on Riders of the Setting Sun, they take that formula and completely reinvent it.
The album opens with the sound of a startled horse, ominous synths and a spoken word introduction delivered by Steve Von Till of Neurosis. With hell they come / With hell they come / Lo, come the horsemen / To bring round the end. Built around a repeating acoustic guitar motif together with an insistent dark, country style rhythm from bassist James Hansen and drummer Isaac Faulk, The Dusklands has a definite sense of purpose. It evokes the image of travelling across a desolate landscape. With occasional interjections of electric guitar, this continued for the first half of the song until there is a change in tempo. Everything slows but the insistence remains. The Dusklands conjures a foreboding aura and while there is a distinctly Western character to the music, dark gothic overtones remain. Shane McCarthy’s vocals draw us effortlessly into the narrative showing Wayfarer have lost none of their storytelling ability and I’ve seen a pale horse and a rider / I’ve seen him bury his head in the sand / Seen a preacher not a poor man / Two fresh laid graves on one plot of land. The Dusklands is a haunting and powerful opening to Riders of the Setting Sun and the first step into the world that Wayfarer have created.
Perdition’s Crossing, which features vocals from David Eugene Edwards (16 Horsepower, Woven Hand), is pure gothic Americana, telling a bleak tale of a rider consumed by violence, guilt and the consequences of his actions. On the plains that I was born / I would stake them down and take them I will make them my own / I’ve been a rider long enough / I know the world is there to fuck and kill and make it my throne. Released as the first single from the album, it received a mixed response from fans with many stating they are not enamoured by the band’s new direction. It cannot be denied that those who are not willing to follow Wayfarer along avenues such as this one are going to find Riders of the Setting Sun a more difficult album to enjoy. However, many of the more sinister elements that have inhabited the band’s music in the past remain albeit now filtered through a different lens. Perdition’s Crossing is a brooding, cinematic track that adds some rockier embellishments during the song’s climax including some wonderful guitar work from McCarthy and Joe Strong. Wayfarer themselves see it as one of the most important tracks on the album. “We have long walked a path that was very much informed by Denver Sound legends like 16 Horsepower and Wovenhand, among many others. To work alongside someone like David Eugene Edwards is not only a bit of a dream come true for us, but also a perfect way for us to start down new roads of the Wayfarer sound that are being fleshed out. We are excited for this collaboration to finally see the light of day.”
Black Roses & Early Graves brings a sombre, melancholic ambience to the fore. The effective use of piano adds a different layer of texture to the track and, as it steadily builds across its first three and a half minutes, it suggests its funereal tone, advancing with a sense of inevitability, will form the entire basis of the track. Then, unexpectedly, it ignites with a guitar solo and some of the most attacking vocals to be found on the album. However, this does not replace what we have heard in the first part of the song but instead seeks to compete with that musical theme and the seemingly unstoppable march of time that the opening section indicates. Eventually, the two parts coalesce into an acoustic outro. It is a demonstration of how Wayfarer can move between seemingly disparate musical forms, bringing together folk elements and heavier passages without either appearing out of place.
If Perdition’s Crossing was enough to upset some fans, then Casey’s Last Ride will make them apoplectic. A cover of one of Kris Kristofferson’s earliest tracks, it tells the story of a lonely, unhappily married man who secretly visits a former lover. Casey joins the hollow sound of silent people walking down / The stairway to the subway in the shadows down below / Following their footsteps through the neon-darkened corridors / Of silent desperation, never speakin' to a soul. While the verses adopt a similar tone and rhythmic structure to The Dusklands or Black Roses & Early Graves, the choruses are a startling departure. Featuring vocals by Kelly Schilling of Dreadnought, they are closer to shoegaze in nature and certainly take some getting used to in this context. It is a perfect example of Wayfarer taking their sound and ripping up the rulebook.
As the album progresses, it is clear that Wayfarer intend to fully embrace their chosen direction. Fell Spur is the most typically country track on the album in terms of its presence and structure. However, the earthy, mournful qualities that flow through the music separate it from the more typical feel of traditional country music. Many of the songs on Riders of the Setting Sun could be used within the soundtrack of a Western and the sense of movement and travel returns.
Grey Country – on which the band are joined by Munly J Munly and Rebecca Vera – tells the tale of a man confronting the consequences of his actions, his legacy and the curse he fears he has passed on to his sons. A mournful gaze is cast / In my direction / One last ride / By light of day / Another has come to pass under my discretion, and I / One last penance I must pay. It is the song that changes most dramatically from beginning to end, opening with a solemn bassline and gentle acoustic guitar as the vocals appear to come from somewhere in the distance before gradually drawing closer. The slow rhythm that follows is by now a familiar feature but electric guitars are soon added, increasing the weight of the music before everything falls back for a quieter central section. When the guitars return, they do so with greater force, leading into the heaviest passage of the record. It never reaches the black metal style for which Wayfarer have become known, instead taking on a more shadowy, gothic character.
Hollow Hearts on the Trail to Eden – my favourite track – has a beautifully delivered vocal from McCarthy which finds him weaving a narrative about a troubled man trying to leave his past behind and find redemption. This hollow heart in time /A cross to bear in silence / Cannot let it weigh me down / A better man than I might / Know where the thread has gone / But that is not my way / And now I’ve come back home. The song possesses an almost spellbinding quality, with its restrained opening gradually drawing us into its world. Just when it seems ready to fully blossom, Wayfarer pull everything back, leaving only acoustic guitar and almost muted spoken word before the gradual ascent begins again. As the song approaches its apparent conclusion, it opens out fully just after the three-and-a-half-minute mark, with one of the few electric guitars heard here taking hold and giving the track a majestic, widescreen character. The guitar solo that follows is rapid, technical and emotional, while the almost mantra-like repetition of Carried in my wake / Carried in spite of my ways, in spite of my ways / Buried with my shame / Buried inside here I lay, inside here I stay brings the song to a remarkable conclusion. It is an emotional highlight and one of the moments that makes you wish Wayfarer had allowed this particular side of their music to emerge more often.
The final track, Prairies of Babylon, once more demonstrates that the quartet have set no limits on what they wanted to achieve, taking their vision to the extreme. With vocal contributions from Madeline Johnston of Midwife, it features elements of ambient, dreampop, shoegaze and drone, together with the hypnotic, immersive qualities that Wayfarer have been exploring throughout the record. As a fan of bands such as MØL and All India Radio, I am perhaps more receptive to this kind of approach than some who are looking for Wayfarer’s metallic edge, but even so, Prairies of Babylon came as something of a surprise on first hearing. Its first three minutes are almost entirely ambient, allowing Johnston’s vocals to sit within a sparse, otherworldly soundscape before the music gradually begins to develop. With each subsequent listen, however, the track has revealed more of its qualities and its position as the closing statement has become increasingly clear. It is an unexpected ending but one that demonstrates a band with complete confidence in the musical path they have chosen.

There is no escaping the fact that Riders of the Setting Sun represents a remarkably bold step for Wayfarer. Rather than merely reducing the metallic elements that once defined their sound, they have largely stepped away from them altogether, placing mood, storytelling and gothic Americana at the very centre of the experience. There are still occasional flashes of electric muscle and moments that hint at the band's heavier past but this is unmistakably a different road. The album's greatest strength lies in the world it creates. Few records this year conjure such a vivid sense of place, its windswept landscapes, haunted characters and lingering undercurrent of loss combining into something deeply immersive. However, the measured pacing that serves the album's carefully cultivated atmosphere can occasionally work against it. Several tracks occupy similar territory and, despite the surprises scattered throughout, a greater degree of contrast would have, at times, been welcome. That said, the album's taut thirty-seven-minute running time largely offsets this, ensuring that the occasional lack of variation never becomes laborious.
Those hoping for a continuation of American Gothic's blend of black metal and Americana may find themselves struggling with the band's new direction, at least initially. Yet there is something admirable about the conviction with which Wayfarer pursue this vision. Rather than repeating a successful formula, they have chosen to follow the path that most interested them artistically, regardless of how fans might respond. With the album veering from post-punk to dark Americana to shoegaze to gothic country, that decision may prove divisive, and it may even cost them some listeners in the short term, but it has resulted in an album with a distinctive identity and a clear sense of purpose. For those willing to walk alongside them, Riders of the Setting Sun offers a richly immersive journey filled with compelling narratives, resonant themes and a carefully realised aesthetic that rarely wavers from its vision. Atmospheric. Courageous. Distinctive.
Riders of the Setting Sun is released on 20th November 2026













Comments